Resources

Definition and Rationale

Alternative grading is an umbrella term for assessment practices that de-emphasize letter grades and points in favor of qualitative feedback and mastery of learning objectives. In the age of generative AI, these methods help shift the focus from “getting the points” to “doing the learning.” Traditional grading often measures compliance rather than actual growth. Switching to an alternative grading model can:

  • Reduce anxiety for students: Lowers the stakes, allowing students to take creative risks without fear of a “GPA-killer” mistake.
  • Discourage academic dishonesty: When the “high-stakes” pressure of a single grade is removed, the incentive to use AI for a “quick fix” decreases.
  • Promote equity: Recognizes that students start at different points and have varying access to resources outside the classroom.

Workshop Position Papers and Presentations

  • Jon Beasley-Murray, “Uproar in the Classroom? Ungrading, Uncertainty, and Trust in the Age of AI”
  • Robin DeRosa, “Money in the (Test) Bank: AI, EdTech, and the Value of Grades.” Video | Slides
  • Tony Mays (Commonwealth of Learning), “Trust, AI, and Assessment” | Video | Slides
  • Pam Kalas (Zoology, UBC), “Four Years of ‘Binning’ (and Counting!)” | Video | Slides
  • Calla Zhang (Liberal Arts, Yorkville University), “Making Learning Visible: Growth over Performance in Liberal Arts Courses” | Video | Slides
  • Miranda Meents, Megan Barker, and Cassandra Pereira (Science/Biological Sciences, SFU), “Ungrading as a Tool in Your Teaching” | Video | Slides
  • Serene Rodrigues (Interdisciplinary Studies, Faculty of Science, UBC), “Instructor Experiences of Alternative Grading at UBC” | Video | Slides

Alternative Grading at UBC

See also this list of courses, compiled by Firas Moosvi.


General Resources

Grades and Alternative Grading

Education and Grading in the Age of AI

  • Report by MIT’s Ad Hoc Committee on AI Use in Teaching, Learning, and Research Training (August 13, 2026)
  • Responsible Assessment in the AI Era by Stanford Accelerator for Learning, supported by the Educational Testing Service (2026)